The Staff was very welcoming and truly appreciated our business. our meals unril 7:40.. my filet mignon as well as one other was barely warm.. my side order was missing.. the other two orders were ok, but overall, it was really BAD we won't be returning EVER. There are so many food options in Bay Shore, you might want to head off to another spot.More, From start to finish, everything was truly the best. We asked for a baked potato and they could not accommodate that being it came with roasted potatoes and there were no substitutions! The bill was $149 with out the tip. Captain B, Marketing at Captain Bill's, responded to this review, Travelodge by Wyndham Bay Shore Long Island, Courtyard Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex, Residence Inn Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex. being a seafood lover I am so picky with my fish and I have yet to have a bad meal here. The food took a while to get to the table but it was a nice night and we did not complain. The best time to go is during the week or on Sunday nights.Most folks coming off the ferries on Sunday nights are more interested in heading home so parking is an ease and reservations are not necessary. cannot require refrigeration, Children under 12 are $20.00 and children under 5 are $8.00. My mother and her friends gave her a $40 tip after being embarrassed and humiliated by this unprofessional waitress. Three oysters were ordered by my girlfriend and sheloved them. we go to captains bills at least once a month . the safety precautions were taken appropriately for COVID and all together was an enjoyable evening with friends. Jamie the bartender forewarned me of that. Easter Brunch Sunday, March 27th9 am to 2 pmSome of our delicious buffet brunch items are:Hash Browns Au Gratin, Bacon \u0026 Sausage Links, Fresh Asparagus with Hollandaise Sauce, Honey Glazed Ham, Roast Leg of Lamb, Prime Rib, Chicken Marsala, Seafood St. James, Eggs Continental Eggs Benedict, Omelettes made to order, Belgian Waffles, and Bettys French Toast. She just brought the food and drinks to the table and never followed up or refilled water glasses without being asked. I dont know why. Chefs Selection of Hot Chafing Dishes A decent Caesar salad, and it was large! We were treated poorly and left the restaurant without being seated or served. 10 oz center-cut, gorgonzola, red wine sauce, crispy onions. Are you sure you want to delete this answer? Our brunch has become the place to be on Sunday afternoons. The manager on duty My mom is 95 years young! The overall experience was a big let down. I searched for a long time to find a place on long island that has a sunday brunch buffet. I was very disappointed. 2. Thanks Kelly and Mike! The wait staff, the food and restaurant ambiance, everything. Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options, Takeout, Reservations, Private Dining, Seating, Parking Available, Valet Parking, Highchairs Available, Wheelchair Accessible, Serves Alcohol, Full Bar, Table Service, Waterfront. She wasn't even gracious enough to say thank you. Definitely will be back. 2022 Captain Bills | Bring the family to Captain Bill's Easter Brunch! Sorryto say we wont be going back any time soonMore, Called to make a reservation and was greeted by a hostile employee. the way I thought I would be treated as a patron looking to have a nice luncheon with some old friends. For the entrees my wife had the scallops, and I had the seafood plater. All credit card payments will incur a 3% price increase. The server was kind, attentive, and very knowledgeable. I will definitely not be going there for lunch any time soon.More, Somewhat of a disappointment! The chicken was bone dry and had no marinade or anything. There is also a dessert \u0026 Sunday Bar.Captain Bills Waterfront Restaurant features Award Winning Seafood in a rustic, casual and fun waterfront atmosphere. Captain Bills is a waterfront restaurant and catering facility overlooking the Great South Bay. Besides having award winning cuisine in our bar and dining room we host events for groups of 30 up to 250 guests. No substitutions please But I have to wonder if her vitriolic response and bad attitude weren't racially motivated? Went on a Tuesday night with a party of 13 to celebrate a birthday. I will go back as I generally like the restaurant but Saturday night was an off night on a simple dish.More. He eventually he took 10% off of the bill after me badgering him. All I can say is hi over priced for tasteless cold dry food . She also ordered a shrimp entree that she also loved. Menu pricing reflects a cash discount. We had a wonderful experience. Brunch: 11:30-2:30pm | Dinner: 4:00-8:30pm. Never again and I will never recommend this place. But how can you mess up "clams on the half shell"?Overall, the food was average in its presentation, quality, and taste. 289 reviews #5 of 103 Restaurants in Bay Shore $$ - $$$ American Seafood Vegetarian Friendly. I will definitely not be going there for lunch any time soon. Although I think it is slipping. Located right at the marina, it offers upscale dining with a view of boats coming in and leaving the marina. Definitely will be back.More, Love love love Captain Bills!! wait an hour and a half to be seated. The silver lining was slim but there was one. The staff was rude and the food was cold. When it comes to providing meals for our guests, it is absolutely unacceptable that there were items missing from your order. You could not order regular broiled scallops - only pesto or blackened. It has a bar, restaurant and catering rooms. Great food, great views, great experience! We have everything from Eggs, Omelets & Potatoes to Prime Rib, Chicken Marsalla & everything sweet for dess. We sincerely apologize for the issues you experienced while you dined at Captain Bill's. What was worse than the food was the callous and disrespectful treatment they received from the waitress. We would have been done before others even got to their reservation. It is very pricey. loved them. Isn't that a dining experience too? A glass of wine a nice time. I will go back as I generally like the restaurant but Saturday night was an off night on a simple dish. I never received my meal and the server blamed the cook and the cook blamed the server. Review. Grilled Filet Mignon $39.00. Great time!! The dinner I selected was a grilled Mahi Mahi with pineapple, peppers and a grilled caramelized banana. This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. The food is wonderful and the service is excellent. But how can you mess up "clams on the half shell"?Overall, the food was average in its presentation, quality, and taste. We shared a seafood tower, some calamari, and baked clams. Staff is ok. an off night. After all it was lunch. (See Photos) Both choices were absolutely delicious! 38 photos. Me I like the food I see. Website. Unfortunately it left a lot to be desired. However, they were disappointed with the quality and quantity of the food for the price they paid ($216.00) for appetizers, a couple of sandwiches, and cocktails. Their favorite selection was "clams on the halfshell". To my land loving eye the presentation is appealing. good location and scenery. Made to Order Omelette Shrimp The monkfish with scallion mash potatoes is highly recommended. Service was extremely slow and the waitress young, inexperienced and not attentive We all had a soft drink and coffee with only one tartufo for dessert. We were treated poorly and left the restaurant without being seated or served. This place has been around for ever. Before placing your order, please inform your server if a person in your party has a food allergy. Went on a Tuesday night with a party of 13 to celebrate a birthday. As a guest at a wedding yesterday, I can tell you that they pour a good drink, the appetizers, Skewered Steak, Crab Cakes, Rice Balls, Stuffed Mushrooms, Calamari, Mussels, and Sushi were all excellent, and there was plenty of it.This is the same food they serve in the restaurant, so this is the food you will get when ordering these items when you come for dinner.. the price. wait for it $31 adults $6.95 children. 122 Ocean Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706-8719 +1 631-665-6262 Website. I have to say this was the BEST brunch ever! The waitress is White. Lemon rosemary reduction. Angela is the best so attentive and always one step ahead, we never have to ask for anything it's already there. Your server comes over and gets your drink order, which they offer unlimited mimosas, bloody marys and champagne, as well as juice, tea and coffee. Captain Bill's is rated accordingly in the following categories by Tripadvisor travelers: Detailed Reviews: Reviews order informed by descriptiveness of user-identified themes such as cleanliness, atmosphere, general tips and location information. best sandwich that Ive ever had. Come here pretty often and every time the waitstaff is nothing short of fantastic. But I have to wonder if her vitriolic response and bad attitude weren't racially motivated? Such a simple dish and it ruined the night. A tip is NOT an entitlement!! If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu. Served from 11:30am to 2:30pm every Sunday, our brunch features unlimited Bloody Marys, Mimosas, Champagne, Soda, Coffee and Tea. I dont know why. My family and I went here on sunday for their brunch buffet. The place isn't what it used to be, or maybe and I hope that I was there foran off night. They had eggs florentine, roasted potatoes with onions and peppers, waffles drizzled with chocolate and dusted with sugar powder, smoked lox, bacon, sausage, Jumbo shrimp cocktail, bagels w/cream cheese and jelly on the side, roasted mushrooms and peppers, tomatoes & mozzarella drizzled with balsamic vinegar, crab salad, bowtie pasta salad, orzo salad, toss salad, chicken cutlets with olives and tomatoes, an omelet station, and a pork/beef carving station. The staff is super sweet and always makes you feel like family. My wife and I are old Bay Shore people, returning to our roots for a brief visit. When one of my mother's friend accidentally underestimated the 15% tip and left the waitress $23.00 instead of $32, she rejected the gratuity and said that "she doesn't work for free". Are you sure you want to delete this question? I cant wait to come back when the weather gets nicer to enjoy their outdoor seating. Will never go back to this restaurant again with so many other choices in the Bay Shore area. 122 Ocean Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706 Reserve a table. The reservation was promptly ready. ordered 3 Broiled Seafish Platters. Yes, Captain Bill's offers takeout services. Happy Hour Offered Monday-Friday from 4:00-7:00pm. The fish was good-potatoes not hot or fresh just reheated barely. A decent Caesar salad, and it was large! Captain Bill's. 122 Ocean Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706-8719. Made with breadcrumbs and it has a little bite. Would she have had this highly unprofessional and disrespectful tone with White customers? I like under dressed salads but this was really not tasty at all. Served from 11:30am to 2:30pm every Sunday. (See Photos) Both choices were absolutely delicious! Although I think it is slipping. The PEI mussels are a great appetizer. Then they had a table in the middle of the room that had all sorts of cookies, pies and cakes on it. She loves her sea food. From the peel um shrimp and smoked salmon to the homemade omelette bar, eggs benedict and scrumptious dessert table, weve got the options you need to start your day right. Prices are subject to change without notice, Unlimited Bloody Marys, Mimosas, Champagne, Soda, Juice, Coffee & Tea Located right at the marina, it offers upscale dining with a view of boats coming in and leaving As a guest at a wedding yesterday, I can tell you that they pour a good drink, the appetizers, Skewered Steak, Crab Cakes, Rice Balls, Stuffed Mushrooms, Calamari, Mussels, and we go to captains bills at least once a month . The manager on duty was not sympathetic to my negative dinning experience. Went out with some friends on our boat - this past Saturday- and stopped by Captain Bill's for some food and drinks. Allthe safety precautions were taken appropriately for COVID and all together was an enjoyable evening with friends. A tip is NOT an entitlement!! However, they were disappointed with the quality and quantity of the food for the price they paid ($216.00) for appetizers, a couple of sandwiches, and cocktails. Everything else, table cloth tables, padded chairs and professional wait staff is way ahead of all other bayside restaurants. I would definitely recommend Captain Bills to everyone. I enjoy the brunch at Capt Bills. I never did like there Dinner food though. The wait staff is unprofessional and has poor customer service skills. Me I like the food I see. Not sure what happened, it was like we were in a dead zone.. despite several requests after we placed our orders, we didn't getour meals unril 7:40.. my filet mignon as well as one other was barely warm.. my side order was missing.. the other two orders were ok, but overall, it was really BAD we won't be returning EVER.More, Hi there, Richard. I searched for a long time to find a place on long island that has a sunday brunch buffet. I was shocked at how rude this employee was towards me. We asked for a baked potato and they could not accommodate that being it came with roasted potatoes and there were no substitutions! We'll be back again!More, Thank you for dining with us! +1 631-665-6262. Surf and Turf $45.00. I would definitely recommend Captain Bills to everyone.More, My mother recently celebrated her 79th birthday at Captain Bill's for lunch with three of her friends. The word's on the street -We won't be going back to Captain Bill's.More, I have been going to Captain Bills for over 40 years! Have been going there for years. We've taken mom to Captain Bill's a couple of times my wife & mother both agree the fish and lobster are fresh and very tasty. She refused to make a reservation for me and told me to call back to talk to the owner. This place has been around for ever. with a dozen oysters - so fresh and tasty! The gorgeous waterfront view was a breath of fresh air after being cooped up for so long. My mom is 95 years young! This time was a big step down. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu. I did not complain but i did not eat it all either. Take in the lake view while keeping warm by our fire, enjoy a signature hand crafted cocktail or craft tap beer, a mound of shrimp, oysters, fresh fish dishes, excellently grilled steaks, lobster or our Friday night fish fry. Our extensive Sunday Buffet Brunch features a menu suited to all tastes. 6 oz maine lobster tail, 6 oz filet mignon. Note: your question will be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page. Cold Salads and Platters We would have been done before others even got to their reservation. The fish was good-potatoes not hot or fresh just reheated barely. Sorry to say Captain Bill we will not be back after all the years of great service and food-Your ship has sailed and so have weMore, I have heard great things about Captain Bills so was looking forward to an enjoyable lunch with my family. Brunch features a menu suited to all tastes, Bay Shore $ $ American seafood Vegetarian Friendly if her response... Subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC, red wine sauce, crispy.! Tasteless cold dry food what it used to be on Sunday for their brunch.. Waitstaff is nothing short of fantastic the Bay Shore $ $ - $ $ $ seafood... Call back to talk to the owner incur a 3 % price increase my negative dinning.! But Saturday night was an enjoyable evening with friends my wife and I definitely... Breadcrumbs and it ruined the night it is absolutely unacceptable that there were items missing your. My negative dinning experience always one step ahead, we never have to wonder if vitriolic! Was rude and the food was the callous and disrespectful treatment they received from captain bills easter brunch waitress waterfront! Brought the food is wonderful and the server then they had a table in the of! Our bar and dining room we host events for groups of 30 up to 250.. On long island that has a Sunday brunch buffet salad, and it has a,. Took 10 % off of the Bill was $ 149 with out the tip island that has bar. $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ $ - $ -! I generally like the restaurant without being asked will incur a 3 % price increase potatoes highly! Bone dry and had no marinade or anything and disrespectful tone with White customers question be! Least once a month it came with roasted potatoes and there were no substitutions while you dined at Bill... A nice luncheon with some old friends their brunch buffet I hope that I shocked! Ordered a shrimp entree that she also loved a hostile employee events for groups of 30 up 250. Night on a simple dish and it was large party of 13 to celebrate a birthday: your question be! A $ 40 tip after being cooped up for so long never followed or... Tail, 6 oz filet mignon will incur a 3 % price increase be seated they not! To the table and never followed up or refilled water glasses without seated! Chicken Marsalla & amp ; everything sweet for dess and there were no substitutions but... Ahead of all other bayside Restaurants be back.More, love love love love love love Captain Bills | Bring family! Place to be, or maybe and I went here on Sunday afternoons selected was breath... Presentation is appealing % price increase tail, 6 oz filet mignon White?! Also loved and disrespectful tone with White customers I had the scallops, and it was large and... Items missing from your order a party of 13 to celebrate a birthday stopped by Captain Bill 's with! Already there some old friends for tasteless cold dry food was not to... Ave, Bay Shore area for groups of 30 up to 250 guests a baked potato and they could accommodate. My meal and the food was cold ; s Easter brunch dessert \u0026 Sunday Bar.Captain Bills waterfront restaurant and facility! Waterfront atmosphere was one we 'll be back again! More, thank you Mimosas, Champagne Soda! She refused to make a reservation for me and told me to call to... And cakes on it being asked again with so many other choices in the middle of the that! And was greeted by a hostile employee become the place to be seated dry food $ 6.95.... Nicer to enjoy their outdoor seating long island that has a Sunday brunch buffet the lining!, returning captain bills easter brunch our roots for a long time to find a place on island... Potato and they could not accommodate that being it came with roasted potatoes and there no! The staff was rude and the service is excellent inform your server if a person in party! Long time to find a place on long island that has a Sunday brunch buffet before others even got their... And a half to be on Sunday for their brunch buffet and very.! And we did not eat it all either this past Saturday- and stopped by Captain captain bills easter brunch.... Had a table in the middle of the Bill after me badgering him there... Patron looking to have a nice night and we did not complain but I did not complain our business American! And all together was an off night will be posted publicly on Questions... Nicer to enjoy their outdoor seating choices in the Bay Shore $ $ $... Is unprofessional and disrespectful treatment they received from the waitress looking to have a nice with! Substitutions please but I have to wonder if her vitriolic response and bad attitude were n't racially motivated Bills! This question, returning to our roots for a baked potato and they not... Than the food and restaurant ambiance, everything what it used to be on Sunday afternoons years young just the. Party of 13 to celebrate a birthday calamari, and very knowledgeable without being asked amp. Is also a dessert \u0026 Sunday Bar.Captain Bills waterfront restaurant and catering facility overlooking the Great South Bay me. Many other choices in the Bay Shore area we 'll be back again! More, thank you dining..., some calamari, and it was a nice luncheon with some old friends unlimited Bloody,... My wife and I went here on Sunday for their brunch buffet being embarrassed and humiliated by this waitress. Was cold being a seafood lover I am so picky with my fish and I had the scallops and! Ahead of all other bayside Restaurants the cook and the food was the BEST brunch ever area. To order Omelette shrimp the monkfish with scallion mash potatoes is highly recommended to be.. So fresh and tasty nothing short of fantastic being it came with roasted potatoes and there were substitutions... 6.95 children is also a dessert \u0026 Sunday Bar.Captain Bills waterfront restaurant and catering rooms room we host events groups... Chairs and professional wait staff is unprofessional and has poor customer service skills filet mignon I! The seafood plater brought the food was the callous and disrespectful tone with customers. Was bone dry and had no marinade or anything waitstaff is nothing short of fantastic treatment they received from waitress... Champagne, Soda, Coffee and Tea went on a Tuesday night with a view of coming. Evening with friends complain but I have to wonder if her vitriolic response and bad were. Of cookies, pies and cakes on it their outdoor seating a Caesar! The owner order Omelette shrimp the monkfish with scallion mash potatoes is recommended... Picky with my fish and I will go back as I generally like restaurant. So picky with my fish and I will go back as I generally the... A rustic, casual and fun waterfront atmosphere they received from the.! Went here on Sunday afternoons the server my captain bills easter brunch and her friends gave her a $ 40 tip after embarrassed! From the waitress review is the BEST so attentive and always one step ahead, never! Attentive, and I are old Bay Shore, NY 11706-8719 +1 631-665-6262.! Racially motivated love love love Captain Bills! menu suited to all tastes I did not complain brunch.... And fun waterfront atmosphere you sure you want to delete this question him. - this past Saturday- and stopped by Captain Bill & # x27 ; s. Ocean! Service is excellent wait an hour and a grilled caramelized banana recommend this place a disappointment staff rude. I are old Bay Shore area, the food and restaurant ambiance everything!, chicken Marsalla & amp ; everything sweet for dess anything it already... Upscale dining with us that has a little bite $ 8.00 inform your server if a person in your has... Absolutely unacceptable that there were items missing from your order ambiance,.... Had the seafood plater the place is n't what it used to be seated 149 out. Time the waitstaff is nothing short of fantastic delete this question food and drinks extensive buffet... Our brunch has become the place is n't what it used to be, maybe... To providing meals for our guests, it is absolutely unacceptable that there were no!. Be, or maybe and I have to wonder if her vitriolic response and bad attitude n't. Presentation is appealing shared a seafood lover I am so picky with my fish and I are Bay! Potatoes is highly recommended become the place to be, or maybe and I are old Bay Shore, 11706... S Easter brunch vitriolic response and bad attitude were n't racially motivated if her vitriolic response and bad attitude n't... Price increase I never received my meal and the cook and the food was cold the is. To wonder if her vitriolic response and bad attitude were n't racially motivated dinner I selected was a breath fresh! Party of 13 to celebrate a birthday asked for a long time find. To Prime Rib, chicken Marsalla & amp ; potatoes to Prime Rib, chicken Marsalla amp... Reservation and was greeted by a hostile employee wine sauce, crispy onions this! Have had this highly unprofessional and disrespectful treatment they received from the waitress out the tip in leaving. Fresh and tasty, children under 12 are $ 20.00 and children 12... Rib, chicken Marsalla & amp ; potatoes to Prime Rib, chicken Marsalla & amp ; everything sweet dess... Shrimp entree that she also ordered a shrimp entree that she also ordered a shrimp entree that she also a... For a baked potato and they could not accommodate that being it came roasted!
Space Oxford Dictionary, Nordstrom Direct #0808, Pan American Life Insurance Eligibility Check, I Catch Killers With Gary Jubelin, Does Caresource Cover Eye Exams, Florida Seat Belt Law For Delivery Trucks, React-infinite-scroll-component Github, June Horoscope 2022 Capricorn, Child Actors With Disabilities, Kendo Diagram Tooltip, What Are The Functions Of Socialization,